The Circle In The Grey

all the rediculous melodrama of an opera, but this is no stage. this is real.

April 03, 2006

On Attending Intelligently to the World

L.B. Meyer:

But to choose prospective certainty over present insight is both mistaken and misguided. It is mistaken because the search for final, definitive answers is an unattainable goal for those concerned with understanding and explanation. For, since the future is open and influential, it can change our understanding both of past compositions and of past historical events. It is misguided - paradoxically so - because the enduring monuments of scholarship, which have shaped men's minds and beliefs, far from being cautious and circumspect, have been those which illuminated a relationship, a work of art, or a past epoch through a bold, encompassing hypothesis.
Now if only i thought it was really that simple...

7 Comments:

At 3:37 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You call infinite complexity and ceaseless (re)speculation simple?

 
At 3:57 PM, Blogger steph said...

no. that was my point. it is not as simple as it looks in ink on paper, at least with these words.

 
At 3:51 PM, Blogger steph said...

and anyhow, i was referring mainly to the first sentence...

 
At 5:59 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Do you think he's right?

 
At 8:32 PM, Blogger steph said...

i don't know. i don't want him to be right.

 
At 8:32 PM, Blogger steph said...

you?

 
At 12:33 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Taken out of the paragraph, I can agree with the first sentence completely. I would have to qualify his subsequent expansion, particularly where he claims "the enduring monuments of scholarship . . . have been those which illuminated a relationship, a work of art, or a past epoch through a bold, encompassing hypothesis." While the enduring monuments are often "encompassing", I have serious reservations about the claim that they are always or even often so (though it is no doubt the encompassing hypotheses that we notice most often), and also serious reservations about Meyer's claim that they are neither "cautious or circumspect". One does not need to be looking for prospective certainty to be cautious or circumspect.

So, I guess the short answer is: maybe, maybe not. Depends on how you gloss it.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home